Victoria hotels clinch top 2 positions in Tripadvisor’s ‘best of the best’

A pair of Victoria hotels have taken the top two positions in the 2025 TripAdvisor Traveller’s Choice Awards for Canadian hotels – an honour that places them among the top one per cent of accommodations worldwide, based on guest reviews and ratings.

Abigail’s Hotel finished in No. 1 for 2025, up from it second-place finish on the coveted list last year.

“Travellers’ Choice is one of the most recognized and coveted awards in the travel space, and it is truly valuable to us,” the hotel said in a social media post. “This achievement would not have been possible without our dedicated staff, whose hard work and passion have made this a reality. We also want to extend our heartfelt thanks to our visitors and reviewers – your support and feedback inspire us to continue creating unforgettable experiences.”

Tripadvisor calls Abigail’s Hotel “a charming, luxurious spot with a convenient location close to Victoria’s Inner Harbour.”

The adult-only, 30-room hotel in a 1930s Tudor mansion, blends the romance of the past with modern comforts including high-end amenities, customer service and breakfasts.

READ MORE: Launch your Greater Victoria vacation with the 2025 Visitor Guide!

Second place position on the “best of the best” list this year is held by Victoria neighbour Magnolia Hotel and Spa.

“This recognition is a reflection of the care and commitment our team brings to the guest experience every day,” general manager Bill Lewis said in a media release. “We’re incredibly proud of our staff for their commitment and dedication, and of our local ownership that has fostered a culture of excellence.”

The hotel features 64 rooms and is known for its focus on service, comfort, and connection to the local community. As a 100 per cent Vancouver Island-owned property, Magnolia Hotel and Spa is committed to showcasing local artisans, producers and experiences through its collection of curated trail maps.

In addition to this latest Tripadvisor award, Magnolia Hotel and Spa was recognized in late 2024 with a Michelin One Key, a distinction given to hotels offering a stay of notable character and quality. It is also the only Vancouver Island hotel to be named to the Travel and Leisure 500 list for two consecutive years (2023, 2024).

READ MORE: City lights, cosy nights: ​​A weekend escape to downtown Victoria

Spots three and four on the TripAdvisor list were occupied by a pair of Vancouver establishments: the Wedgewood Hotel and Spa and the Loden Hotel. Vancouver’s Exchange Hotel slotted at No. 6, and the Okanagan’s Summerland Waterfront Resort & Spa was number 8 to round out B.C.’s contributions to the top 10. The Watermark Beach Resort in Osoyoos was ranked 11th.

The Summerland property received the Travelers’ Choice Award and Best of the Best Award, and was named one of the Top 25 Hotels in Canada.

“We are beyond honoured to be recognized with these three prestigious TripAdvisor awards,” said Lisa Jaager, general manager of the resort. “To be named among the top hotels in the country – and in the world – means that our guests see and appreciate the care our team puts into every stay.”

A social media post from Watermark Beach Resort thanked visitors who left 4.9-star reviews on Tripadvisor.

“Thank you for every kind review, return visit and shared memory. We look forward to another amazing year ahead,” the post stated.

The Travellers’ Choice Awards are issued to those who receive a high volume of above-and-beyond reviews and opinions from the Tripadvisor community over a 12-month period. Out of eight million listings, fewer than one per cent achieve this milestone.

Find the full list at a tripadvisor.ca.

Plan your adventures throughout the West Coast at westcoasttraveller.com and follow us on Facebook and Instagram @thewestcoasttraveller. And for the top West Coast Travel stories of the week delivered right to your inbox, sign up for our weekly Armchair Traveller newsletter!