Mobile Menu

  • Destinations
    • Canada
      • British Columbia
        • Vancouver Island, B.C.
        • Okanagan
        • Lower Mainland, B.C.
        • Northern B.C.
        • Interior B.C.
        • Kootenays/Rockies
      • Alberta
      • Yukon
      • Northwest Territories
    • U.S.A.
      • Alaska
      • Washington
      • Oregon
      • California
    • West Coast Galleries
  • Experiences
    • West Coast Galleries
      • Nature Photography
      • Wildlife Photography
      • Cityscapes
    • Things To Do
    • Staycation Secrets
      • Canada
      • U.S.A.
    • Adventure
      • Adrenaline
      • Beaches
      • Biking
      • Camping
      • Fishing
      • Hiking
      • Hunting and Fishing
      • Rafting
      • Skiing
    • Sip & Savour
    • Family Activities
    • Indigenous Tourism
    • Accessible Travel
    • Travel Tips & Advisories
  • Newsletter Sign-up
  • Contests
  • About
    • The Armchair Traveller Newsletter
    • Explore our travel guides
    • Impressive West Coast
    • West Coast Partners
    • West Coast Traveller Directory
    • Join Our Team
    • Contact Us
    • Terms of Service
    • Explore West Coast Traveller on TikTok
  • Search
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • TikTok Icon
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
  • Flickr Icon
  • Menu
  • Skip to left header navigation
  • Skip to right header navigation
  • Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to secondary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Before Header

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • TikTok Icon
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
  • Flickr Icon

West Coast Traveller

  • Destinations
    • Canada
      • British Columbia
        • Vancouver Island, B.C.
        • Okanagan
        • Lower Mainland, B.C.
        • Northern B.C.
        • Interior B.C.
        • Kootenays/Rockies
      • Alberta
      • Yukon
      • Northwest Territories
    • U.S.A.
      • Alaska
      • Washington
      • Oregon
      • California
    • West Coast Galleries
  • Experiences
    • West Coast Galleries
      • Nature Photography
      • Wildlife Photography
      • Cityscapes
    • Things To Do
    • Staycation Secrets
      • Canada
      • U.S.A.
    • Adventure
      • Adrenaline
      • Beaches
      • Biking
      • Camping
      • Fishing
      • Hiking
      • Hunting and Fishing
      • Rafting
      • Skiing
    • Sip & Savour
    • Family Activities
    • Indigenous Tourism
    • Accessible Travel
    • Travel Tips & Advisories
  • Newsletter Sign-up
  • Contests
  • About
    • The Armchair Traveller Newsletter
    • Explore our travel guides
    • Impressive West Coast
    • West Coast Partners
    • West Coast Traveller Directory
    • Join Our Team
    • Contact Us
    • Terms of Service
    • Explore West Coast Traveller on TikTok
  • Search
You are here: Home / news / Parks Canada plans major rewrite of more than 200 historic site plaques

Parks Canada sites slated for rewrite of their historic site plaques include fur trade forts such as Fort Langley in British Columbia. Jen Blyth / West Coast Traveller photo

Parks Canada plans major rewrite of more than 200 historic site plaques

May 31, 2023 //  by The Canadian Press

Share this:

They’re affixed to old buildings where someone important used to live. Or they’re mounted on a rock overlooking somewhere where something once happened.

Cast in bronze or lettered on a sign, they’re sometimes the only history lesson many of us ever get. And now Parks Canada wants hundreds of them changed.

“The way that many of the national historic designations are framed and positioned does not do justice to the breadth of impacts that they had on Canadian society,” said Patricia Kell, the agency’s director of heritage.

Parks is in the middle of a three-year program to re-examine and rewrite the plaques that the Historic Sites and Monuments Board use to point out places deemed important to understanding Canada’s past.

Sites slated for rewrite include fur trade forts such as Fort Langley in British Columbia and Manitoba’s York Factory. Others relate to the War of 1812, like Queenston Heights in Ontario.

Some involve historic figures who held beliefs at odds with current standards. They include one of the Fathers of Confederation, John A. Macdonald; Archibald Belaney, otherwise known as Grey Owl; and Nicholas Flood Davin, founder of one of the West’s first newspapers.

The rationale for the changes, as well as a list of priority sites, is outlined in a document obtained under Freedom of Information legislation.

Fort Langley National Historic Site, British Columbia. Of the 2,192 historic Parks Canada sites, about two-thirds of plaque texts are fine. Of the remainder, more than 200 are considered high priorities for change. Jen Blyth / West Coast Traveller photo

The document says that out of 2,192 historic sites, about two-thirds of plaque texts are fine. Of the remainder, more than 200 are considered high priorities for change.

Reasons include ignoring Indigenous contributions or using antiquated language, such as “Indian” or “Eskimo.” Another issue is controversial beliefs held by historical figures.

The most common reason for rewriting — covering plaques for French explorer Jacques Cartier, Alberta’s Bar U Ranch and Nunavut’s Kekerten Island Whaling Station — are “colonial assumptions,” the document says.

“Plaque texts can be described as ‘Whiggish’ in character,” it says. “This refers to a form of history where the progress of western civilization is understood as inevitable.

“Earlier assumptions about Canadian history that have excluded Indigenous people, among others, can no longer be accepted.”

Those plans have drawn accusations of presentism — the mistake of judging the past by standards of the present. Such charges have been levelled by Larry Ostola, former vice-president of heritage conservation at Parks Canada.

“A new woke perspective is being imposed on what was formerly an apolitical, fact-driven historical designation process,” he wrote in the National Post.

But Kell said the changes are being partly driven by the 2015 report of the Truth and Reconciliation Commission. One of the calls to action recommended Canada “develop a reconciliation framework for Canadian heritage and commemoration.”

She said it’s an attempt to use the latest scholarship to broaden the stories told, not erase familiar ones.

“They build on what was there before. They take that as a starting point and add additional layers and voices.

“It’s important to continue to reflect on these events. There are additional layers of understanding about them and some of those understandings are not celebratory.”

Many of the high-priority sites are old fur trade forts.

“Many designations associated with the fur trade have excluded the essential role of Indigenous people,” the document says. “By … providing recognition of the necessary partnership that existed between the two cultures, this gap in historical significance will begin to be rectified.”

Concerns over how Indigenous perspectives are included also affects sites associated with the War of 1812, in which many First Nations warriors fought alongside British troops and Canadian militias.

Other plaques are trying to come to grips with ideas many famous and accomplished Canadians publicized that are today considered abhorrent.

William Osler, sometimes called the father of modern medicine, mocked Indigenous people and wrote Canada “should be a white man’s country.”

But Bob Coutts, for many years the chief historian of the Historic Sites and Monuments Board, said it’s a mug’s game trying to decolonize sites that are historic, largely because of their role in colonization.

“The story still focuses on a colonialist story,” he said. “You could pad it a little bit, but it’s still going to be a plaque about the building of a fur trade fort.”

As well, the whole idea of plaques depends on written history. That works against Indigenous history, Coutts said.

“Those rules lend themselves to white, colonialist history. Someone wrote it down.”

What gets commemorated is changing, said Kell.

“We are actively working with members of a variety of communities who have not been well served in order to ensure there are subjects of importance to them that are becoming part of our national program of commemoration.”

Priority areas for that effort include the history of diversity, Indigenous history and environmental history.

Still, messing with history is always going to be complicated, said Coutts.

“I love stories that are complex. That’s what history is. There isn’t a narrative that goes from A to B.

“On the other hand, there’s still a story in there somewhere that needs to be told.”

— Bob Weber, The Canadian Press, with files from researcher Ken Rubin in Ottawa

* * * * *

Plan your adventures throughout the West Coast at westcoasttraveller.com and follow us on Facebook and Instagram @thewestcoasttraveller. And for the top West Coast Travel stories of the week delivered right to your inbox, sign up for our weekly Armchair Traveller newsletter!

Share this:

Category: news, TravelTag: Canada, Parks Canada

Related Posts

You may be interested in these posts from the same category.

5 ways to take an affordable family vacation this summer

You want to create memories and have a great time with your family this summer.…

5 ways to take an affordable family vacation this summerRead More

48 hours in Nelson, B.C.: Trails, taps and laid-back charm

I rolled into Nelson on a warm Friday morning, welcomed by a mix of fresh…

48 hours in Nelson, B.C.: Trails, taps and laid-back charmRead More

Brick-by-brick, stories beyond the history come alive in Kelowna this summer

Brick-by-brick, Canadian artist Ekow Nimako re-imagined ancient African kingdoms by building and envisioning a journey…

Brick-by-brick, stories beyond the history come alive in Kelowna this summerRead More

Salish Sea’s first humpback whale calf of 2025 spotted off B.C. south coast

The first humpback whale calf of 2025 has arrived in the Salish Sea, according to…

Salish Sea’s first humpback whale calf of 2025 spotted off B.C. south coastRead More

This Sooke, B.C. destination was made for fun in summer sun

Since the late 1800s, the uniquely carved series of polished rock pools and tunnels in…

This Sooke, B.C. destination was made for fun in summer sunRead More

5 Washington towns perfect for a spontaneous weekend adventure

Looking for a little escape from the mundane? Washington is filled with quaint towns you…

5 Washington towns perfect for a spontaneous weekend adventureRead More

VIDEO: Empress and the beast: Victoria hotel’s turf war with marmot Roger

Mischievous beasts outwitting their human foes is a tale as old as time – Peter…

VIDEO: Empress and the beast: Victoria hotel’s turf war with marmot RogerRead More

Venturing into Khutzeymateen: Canada’s only grizzly bear sanctuary

Hidden deep in northwest British Columbia’s coast lies the lush inlet of the Khutzeymateen, bustling…

Venturing into Khutzeymateen: Canada’s only grizzly bear sanctuaryRead More

ValhallaFest music festival rises from B.C. old growth forest

Set against the backdrop of an old-growth forest near Terrace, B.C., ValhallaFest is where music…

ValhallaFest music festival rises from B.C. old growth forestRead More

Previous Post: « Victoria International Airport welcomes new airline with Friday Harbor route
Next Post: Guided June hikes explore old-growth forests in seven Kootenay communities »

Primary Sidebar

Things To Do

5 ways to take an affordable family vacation this summer

June 11, 2025

48 hours in Nelson, B.C.: Trails, taps and laid-back charm

June 10, 2025

Brick-by-brick, stories beyond the history come alive in Kelowna this summer

June 9, 2025

Salish Sea’s first humpback whale calf of 2025 spotted off B.C. south coast

June 9, 2025

Recent Posts

5 ways to take an affordable family vacation this summer

June 11, 2025

48 hours in Nelson, B.C.: Trails, taps and laid-back charm

June 10, 2025

Brick-by-brick, stories beyond the history come alive in Kelowna this summer

June 9, 2025

Salish Sea’s first humpback whale calf of 2025 spotted off B.C. south coast

June 9, 2025

Footer

The West Coast Traveller has an immense social media footprint, with eight social media sites and and 125,000+ social followers.

Join us on social media and Join Our Community by sharing your stuff!

Get Inspired

News Media Groups

Black Press Media
Sound Publishing
Oahu Media Group
Alaska
Boulevard Magazines
Used.ca

Let’s Get Social

West Coast Traveller
I Love British Columbia
I Love Alberta
I Love Yukon
I Love Northwest Territories
I Love Washington
I Love California
I Love Oregon
I Love Alaska

Visit Our Companion Sites

I Love Saskatchewan
I Love Manitoba
I Love Nunavut
I Love Ontario
I Love Quebec
I Love Newfoundland and Labrador
I Love Nova Scotia
I Love New Brunswick
I Love Prince Edward Island

Site Footer

  • Facebook
  • Flickr
  • Instagram
  • TikTok Icon
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

Copyright © 2025 West Coast Traveller and · All Rights Reserved